Carles prepares a post about the decade in music.


Yall. I feel tons of pressure to write a ‘best of year’/'best of decade’/'best of century post.’
I am not sure what I should take into consideration. Really want to ‘figure out’ the last decade, not just spooge over artists.

Who was the most relevant musician of the 2k0 decade?
How did ‘indie’ become what it is?
Who is ‘the most important artist of the decade’?
Is Radiohead the most important band of ‘our generation’?
Is ‘the Animal Collective’ too new 2 be considered on a best of decade list?
Which genres/bands ‘came and went’?
Was American Idol more relevant than the bloghouse/indie movement?
Are women important 2 the music scene?
Did 1 album/band change the world/scene?
Will ‘buzzbands’ exist in the next decade?
Who is ‘the beatles’ of the decade?
Do tweens know how to steal music since they never had a Napster console?
What genre/movement/band has been ‘overlooked’ in most Decade recapping posts?
Have black artists been over-represented by ‘respected’ music zine sites?
Which musician did the most for the betterment of the world, besides making critically acclaimed albums?
Are musicians ‘real humans’, ‘artists’ or ‘a whole nother beast’?
Do the Strokes still have alternative credibility?
Was the Arcade Fire really even ‘that good’?
What ever happened 2 ‘emo’?
When did u get ur first iPod?

Was 2k0 the best decade in the history of music?

Need yalls help. Not sure what just happened in the last decade.
Sorta miss 90s alt rock, back before there were so many alt-niches.

     
This entry was posted in Important Opinions on Alternative Music. Bookmark the permalink. Trackbacks are closed, but you can post a comment.

92 Comments

  1. !!!
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:46 pm | Permalink

    first

    Reply

    wigwog

    //////////Reply by wigwog
    //////////Posted

    @!!!,
    THE MILLIONAIRES were the altest/most relevant band of the decade / any decade / the future of music.

    Reply

    jig

    //////////Reply by jig
    //////////Posted

    @wigwog, leave his ‘first’ alone, why dont u

    Reply

    hitlerh8r69

    //////////Reply by hitlerh8r69
    //////////Posted

    @!!!, Rites that the Vedas ordain, and the rituals taught by the scriptures: all these am I, and the offering made to the ghosts of the fathers, herbs of healing and food, the mantram, the clarified butter: I the oblation and I the flame into which it is offered, I am the sire of the world, and this world’s mother and grandsire: I am He who awards to each the fruit of his action: I make all things clean, I am OM.

    Reply

    fullscale008

    //////////Reply by fullscale008
    //////////Posted

    @hitlerh8r69, OBAMAPACALYPSE

    Reply

  2. ames
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:49 pm | Permalink

    2nd

    Reply

  3. Carlesfan420
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:50 pm | Permalink

    im gay

    Reply

    teh

    //////////Reply by teh
    //////////Posted

    @Carlesfan420, me2, i love ghey

    Reply

    Jurgis

    //////////Reply by Jurgis
    //////////Posted

    @Carlesfan420, samez, i love havin my anus ’stuck’ with a peen.

    Reply

    jjj

    //////////Reply by jjj
    //////////Posted

    @Jurgis, word.

    Reply

  4. lam
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:54 pm | Permalink

    The Arcade Fire was never good.

    Reply

    neverafterlater

    //////////Reply by neverafterlater
    //////////Posted

    @lam, wrong

    Reply

    ftwin butler

    //////////Reply by ftwin butler
    //////////Posted

    @neverafterlater, LIES, LIES

    Reply

    generk witty cmmnt

    //////////Reply by generk witty cmmnt
    //////////Posted

    @lam,
    Must’ve been before your time, you vile youngster!

    Reply

    ohnosphaghetticat

    //////////Reply by ohnosphaghetticat
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt, AGREE

    Reply

    ripples

    //////////Reply by ripples
    //////////Posted

    @lam, right.

    A couple okay songs that have zero lasting power, and lots of filler. Really really overrated.

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @ripples, Yeah lets get one thing straight. Arcade Fire fucking sucks! That album is old after the fifth listen, so go delete it from your itunes. I win

    Reply

    antithesis

    //////////Reply by antithesis
    //////////Posted

    @ripples, this is the worst analysis ever….first of all, lasting power is an entity too illusive to be tackled in two sentences by a wayward bro such as urself. Second, Arcade Fire is a great band! They have successfully produced two amazingly solid albums filled with beautiful originality and subtle accessibility to match.

    Reply

    generk witty cmmnt

    //////////Reply by generk witty cmmnt
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis,
    y’all
    anyone who hates the arcade fire is just too young to understand what it meant 2 be earnest.

    ~~~**~~~
    miss u, late 2k4/early 2k5.
    miss u, the first time I heard TVOR’s best song, ’staring at the sun.’
    miss u, ‘garden state.’
    miss u, dirty chuck taylors.
    miss u, white ipod.
    miss u, ’silent alarm.’
    miss u, team zissou.
    miss u, late 2k4/early 2k5.
    ~~~**~~~

    antithesis

    //////////Reply by antithesis
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt, wow bro. feel like u just caressed my heart and soul. every word was true alt poetry.
    R.I.P. Spike Jonze

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis, <3 yall

    yall change all the lead
    sleepin in my head

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt,

    My loving mother kindly brought me into this world Tuesday, April 7, 1987. I am 22.673213 years old. I listened to the Arcade Fire for the first time in 2003 in my underwear after downloading their at-the-time unreleased ep ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arcade_Fire_(EP) ). I was 16 years old. I was a virgin [via tragic altness]. It was unlike anything that I had ever downloaded [via DC++]. It was unlike anything Clear Channel Communications, Inc. had ever broadcast on the three radio stations my small town received. It smelled like a Tim Burton forest full of deviance and youth. Us kids know, Arcade Fire changed our lives. They played out of our car stereos [via 'burning mp3s to CD-R]. They played on our First Generation iPods. They played at our cabin boozefests. They played at our exchange student weekend retreats. They played out of the speakers at our friends’ weddings. They played with LCD Soundsytem October 6th, 2007, at Randall’s Island.

    We kept the car running at the passion pits long before Sleepyhead.

    Growing up in a super saturation of corporate and classic rock, Arcade Fire was somehow ours, it was fresh, it was okay to lose yourself in. And Neon Indian was a necessary catharsis to the Bush years.

    generk witty cmmnt, I want to hug you right now. I feel old and nostalgic for the simpler days before this post-modern soup we’re all swimming in, before music could be explained in Six Songs. I miss the old days when music was a sport you could excel at. I miss worrying about ‘losing my edge’ back when blogging wasn’t just a bad case of narcissism and ADHD. I miss the mystery and magic before mp3s turned everything into a personalized egocast.

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis, Neon Indian was a freudian slip of Neon Bible.

    Neon Bible > Neon Indian

    kswift

    //////////Reply by kswift
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis,

    Garden St8 and Arc8 Fires defined me as an alt back when I was tweening out in 2k5. Stop h8n.

    Surfster

    //////////Reply by Surfster
    //////////Posted

    @ripples, this thread is hilarious. Arcade Fire is awesome, but they are no longer alt. That happened the day their song went into the trailer for ‘Where the Wild Things Are’ and the aqua-cize teacher at the pool where I work put it on her water aerobic mix tape. Wish I could video tape these old people bobbing up and down to the Arcade Fire for ya’ll. Thought you should know.

    Reply

    generk witty cmmnt

    //////////Reply by generk witty cmmnt
    //////////Posted

    @Surfster,
    ‘In the third millennium there is to be:
    ~no myth but the business myth,

    ~no individuality but the thirty or so professionally-accepted psychographic market niches,

    ~no rebellion but the pre-programmed search for new [p4k reviews].

    We will be able to achieve no distance from business culture since we will no longer have a life, a history, a consciousness apart from it.

    It is making itself unspeakable, too big, too obvious, too vast, too horrifying, too much of a cliche to even begin addressing.

    A matter-of-fact disaster, as natural as the supermarket, as resistible as air. It is putting itself beyond our power of imagining because it has become our imagination, it has become our power to envision, and describe, and theorize, and resist.”

    –thomas frankbro

    bet walt whitman ceased 2 be a poet once levi’s used him in a commercial.
    bet william burroughs was forgotten once he appeared in an ad 4 nike.
    bet u stopped listening 2 saul williams once he appeared in an ad 4 nike.

    good job being taught that something’s worth depends on who consumes it. marketing has taught u well.

    ‘we know a place where no brands go
    we know a place where no ads go

    (hey!) no ‘alts’ go
    (hey!) no ‘alts’ go
    where we know

    we know a place no product placements go
    we know a place where no fixed gears go

    (hey!) no ‘alts’ go
    (hey!) no ‘alts’ go
    where we know’

    ::!!maybe that place if inside of us, y’all!!::
    ::!!maybe that is wut the arcade fire meant 2 us!!::

    we. were. never. alt.
    we. wanted. more.
    we wanted 2 b
    free

    Surfster

    //////////Reply by Surfster
    //////////Posted

    @Genny Witty Shizm,

    Thought claiming somebody ‘was no longer alt’ was tongue in cheek, as it is a tenuous concept not to be taken seriously and the youngsters seem to be talking mad shit on Arcade Fire.

    Was not expecting a diatribe, that was epic.

    Burroughs was in a Nike ad? Damn. Syringes have really taken over the big leagues.

    You should seriously see these old folks doing aquacize to Arcade Fire though, it’s amazing.

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @Surfster, And the prophet said preach!

    monster

    //////////Reply by monster
    //////////Posted

    @SilverTell
    DC++ was the shit. Ind!ous life made me what I am today. Now Google is just 100000x easier.

    Reply

  5. aw, fukk
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:57 pm | Permalink

    generationals = <3

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, heard them [via hypem then urb outfitties lstn mxtpe]. enjoy them also.

    Reply

    iampaco

    //////////Reply by iampaco
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, love dem fucking generationals!!!!! Cuz when they fight they fight!

    Reply

  6. Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:57 pm | Permalink

    pickles

    Reply

    anjelica pickles

    //////////Reply by anjelica pickles
    //////////Posted

    @Christian, sup

    Reply

  7. Jewethan
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 4:59 pm | Permalink

    I feel like Brian McKnight was the best artist of this decade. He’s suave like a man should be.

    Reply

    -_-_-_

    //////////Reply by -_-_-_
    //////////Posted

    @Jewethan, agreed.

    too many artists in the 2k0’s focused on the ‘zany indie’ aesthetic (remember Architecture in Helsinki?)

    it’s the end of the decade.

    and i realize now that what i really wanted all along was playing in the stereo on display at the Sharper Image.

    <3 u BMcK

    Reply

    Lord B

    //////////Reply by Lord B
    //////////Posted

    @Jewethan, My vote for artist of the decade is Lil Jon.

    YEAH!
    WHAT!
    OK!

    He made a huge cultural impact. So much joy and laughter was brought by him/Dave Chappelle. The 2000’s will always remind me of Lil Jon. He’s hilarious!

    Reply

    leprechaun in alabam

    //////////Reply by leprechaun in alabam
    //////////Posted

    @Lord B,

    i vote for jack johnson
    not only does he get low
    he gets mellow

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @leprechaun in alabam, I kinda agree although I could easily be made fun of – maybe its from my love affair with the surf or maybe I’m just a little cheesy sometime, but i don’t hate a little flake… His surf album soundtracks are seriously good shit though, M. Ward, Johnny Osbourne, Vedder on Uke – some feel good shit right there

  8. jig
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:01 pm | Permalink

    LEN steal my sunshine #1

    Reply

    HJ

    //////////Reply by HJ
    //////////Posted

    @jig, luv u jig see u L.A.T.E.R. on this week

    Reply

    Carlesfan420

    //////////Reply by Carlesfan420
    //////////Posted

    @jig, agreedo

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @jig, released in ‘99. one of my fave albums ever. srsly.

    cryptic souls crew yall

    Reply

    jig

    //////////Reply by jig
    //////////Posted

    @jig, LEN was proto-chillwave, T/F?

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @jig, still have totally ‘real’ experiences to that song. people who know the words i feel like ‘get me’ on a different level than those who do not. JARED I LOVE YOU!

    Reply

  9. eliza thornberry
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:07 pm | Permalink

    neutral milk hotel

    boobs

    Reply

    silverstar

    //////////Reply by silverstar
    //////////Posted

    @eliza thornberry, just listened to in the aeroplane over the sea before reading this. realized that 2K.0.1-9 never produced nething close. wait, what about the microphones?

    Reply

    Anonymous

    //////////Reply by Anonymous
    //////////Posted

    @silverstar, The Microphones FTW

    Reply

    b4hc

    //////////Reply by b4hc
    //////////Posted

    @Anonymous, most meaningful artist of the decade

  10. bwllmb
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:09 pm | Permalink

    Feel like I am ’supposed 2 think’ that the artist of the decade was Jay-Z. Feel like ‘I don’t rlly think that’.

    But he does like theGrizzlingBears. So maybe.

    Is it alt 2 pick an ‘artist of the decade’ w/an animal name in the band name? Feel like I should pick AnCo, GrizzBear, Panda Bear, FleetFoxing, the Mtn Goats, Wolf Parade, Wolfmothers, Dept of Grizzlings, Deerhuntings, Deerhooves, ModularMice, etc.

    Reply

    vlad

    //////////Reply by vlad
    //////////Posted

    @bwllmb, all the tweens on the PATH train after the ‘All Points West’ palooza fest were like ‘I saw Jay-Z perform at this little club in Virginia Beach’ and ‘fuck the Vampire Weekend, they were ghey’.

    Jay-Z is tween Radiohead/Jesus… bmrz.

    Now I feel the cold grip of father times’ fingerz. I’m growing up.

    Reply

    Blackface Killah

    //////////Reply by Blackface Killah
    //////////Posted

    @vlad, at least we will always have Ether

    @Jay-Z, ‘You pop shit’

    miss u nasty nAS

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @bwllmb, ModularMice ftw! (((Modular Recordings + Modest Mouse = the place where the 90s met the 00s)))

    Reply

  11. aw, fukk
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:12 pm | Permalink

    baby walrus = <3

    Reply

    aw, fukk

    //////////Reply by aw, fukk
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, http://leftshoedistrict.tumblr.com/post/284293943/red-horses-by-baby-walrus

    Reply

  12. anjelica pickles
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:12 pm | Permalink

    overlooked bands:
    brand new
    have a nice life
    hercules & love affair
    bright eyes (feverz & mirrorz yall)
    odd nosdom
    eluvium
    emily haines
    oceanographer

    Reply

    lazerbear

    //////////Reply by lazerbear
    //////////Posted

    @anjelica pickles, brand new was overlooked for a good reason.

    they suck.

    Reply

    anjelica pickles

    //////////Reply by anjelica pickles
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, :o

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, 4 realz

    Reply

    Montauk Monstah

    //////////Reply by Montauk Monstah
    //////////Posted

    @anjelica pickles, miss u 2k3-5 ‘Long Island is the Seattle of Emo’ era.

    Wait. No. I don’t.

    Miss you 99-2k1 ‘Long Island is the Seattle of Ska’ era. You were way more fun.

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @Montauk Monstah, there is so much wrong with that. Long island the Seattle of Ska? try Jamaica if that doesnt work try coventry in England if that doesnt work try Socal in the mid 90’s Long island can lick my balls

    Reply

    ThatsNotAltBro

    //////////Reply by ThatsNotAltBro
    //////////Posted

    @anjelica pickles,

    No way Hercules & Love Affair was overlooked & isn’t Brand New a crappy “scene music” band? Meh

    Reply

  13. HJ
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:12 pm | Permalink

    lucky by lucky twice kinda miss amycore via 2k8 summer wonder if she grew up and became an art something or other…
    http://www.hipsterrunoff.com/2008/07/what-music-will-sound-likemusic-videos-will-look-like-in-2k8.html
    was kinda sad when they took this vid down :(

    Reply

  14. sher derrup
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:21 pm | Permalink

    st. ides > colt 45

    Reply

    Jewethan

    //////////Reply by Jewethan
    //////////Posted

    @sher derrup,

    Maniishevitz > St. Ides

    Reply

    women

    //////////Reply by women's studies 101
    //////////Posted

    @sher derrup, st ides heaven am i rite

    Reply

  15. lazerbear
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:27 pm | Permalink

    what do you guys think about radiohead? ‘kid a’ is apparently THE album of the decade. i dunno if i agree with that. just because they did it first doesn’t make it the best.

    but it is a pretty good album.
    but still.
    does it DEFINE our decade? hopefully not. it was pretty depressing at a lot of parts.

    Reply

    generk witty cmmnt

    //////////Reply by generk witty cmmnt
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear,
    ( ) = best of the decade.

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, the only reason any of these albums get consideration in the ‘best of decade’ is cause OK Computer came out in the ’90s. Same with Neutral Milk Hotel. Feel like some of the best music of the 2k0’s came out in the late 90’s. Sorry youngsters!

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, feel like it is probs radioheads second best album (next 2 ok compy). it is ‘fucking sweet’ but i’d h8 2 think the best album of our decade is radiohead’s 2nd best album bcuz that would imply that nothing in the past 10 yrs is better than ok computer (via logic).

    Reply

    Surfster

    //////////Reply by Surfster
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, just because you ‘[don't] feel it’, doesn’t mean it’s [not] there [on top of the list]

    Reply

    g-a

    //////////Reply by g-a
    //////////Posted

    @Surfster, ‘fucking sweet’ reference. wrong album tho.

    Reply

  16. pookie
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:35 pm | Permalink

    nvr 4get pinback.

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, summer in abaddon

    Reply

    pookie

    //////////Reply by pookie
    //////////Posted

    @chilisfan, hells yes

    Reply

    mr. jeffers

    //////////Reply by mr. jeffers
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, i remember hearing penelope for the first time in this snowboarding video called white balance. it went perfectly with the visuals

    jjj

    //////////Reply by jjj
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, omguh! Sad I’m gonna die… hope it’s gonna happen laaatterrr.

    Reply

    women

    //////////Reply by women's studies 101
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, most boring band ever

    Reply

  17. gagaloo
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:44 pm | Permalink

    @The Strokes
    LAWL.

    Reply

    Elle

    //////////Reply by Elle
    //////////Posted

    @gagaloo, Lawl all you want but the strokes really are an important band of the early 00’s. You must be 14 years old.

    Reply

    generk witty cmmnt

    //////////Reply by generk witty cmmnt
    //////////Posted

    @gagaloo,
    fggt.

    Reply

  18. Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:49 pm | Permalink

    Gogol Bordello

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @Dan, fuck. you.

    Reply

  19. Madame Ovary
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:49 pm | Permalink

    Strokes, Arcade Fire, Radiohead, all that garbage…

    Reply

  20. \\\\\\\\\\
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 5:58 pm | Permalink

    1.Lil John and The East Side boys (via 00’s being abt cumming all over errthang and gettin low).
    2.The internet and kewt baristas
    3.
    4. No, well maybe. I dunno abt Thom’s squinty eye.
    5. Well they’re kinda a big thing, but MWPP is kinda 2 new for ‘best album’ maybe ‘Tung Songs’ is fair game.
    6. Crazy Town, Limp Bizkit and ‘Rock Rap’ is way gone
    7. No. History will reveal in time…
    8. Yeah (via good music bros performing ‘to hit that shit l8r’) and by breaking up good bands and CSS.
    9.The Black Eye’d peas won the election 4 Barry.
    10. But they will only b popular 4 17 days.
    11. Whomever used Autotune on a rap song 1st (Tpain?)
    12.Do yall know where water comes from when u turn on the Tapster.
    23.Reggaeton
    14. only the ones white ppl feel comfortable around
    16. Snoop Dogg started ’snooper bowl’ 4 da kidz.
    16. Real Humans with Real Emotions and Real Tight Whips.
    17. Hell No.
    18. Don’t think so. Canadians r strange ppl yall.
    19. Ppl made fun of emos on the internet and they stopped acting retarded
    20. Still using MiniDiscs

    Reply

    femanon

    //////////Reply by femanon
    //////////Posted

    @\\\\\, Rock Rap? It’s called nu-metal faggot

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @femanon, come on now, really?

    Reply

    \\\\\\\\\\

    //////////Reply by \\\\\\\\\\
    //////////Posted

    @femanon, should have said ‘Rapcore’ u want 2 meet up 4 tugjobs later?

    Reply

    Chris Hansen

    //////////Reply by Chris Hansen
    //////////Posted

    @femanon, You know the rules, tits or gtfo cumdumpster.

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @Chris Hansen, please leave, 4chanbro. yall don’t belong here.

    ~peace out~

    RoboRapist

    //////////Reply by RoboRapist
    //////////Posted

    @\\\\\, I hope this shit is a joke

    Reply

  21. brobro
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:11 pm | Permalink

    The Radioheads released many albums which received critical acclaim but which also ’sold a shit-ton’ of copies. They are the ‘Beatles’ of our generation.

    The Animal Collectivists released a number of albums which were critically acclaimed and possibly more musically complex than the Radioheads’, but did not sell quite the ’shit-ton’ of albums that Radiohead did. The are the ‘Beach Boys’ of our generation.

    The White Stripes released a number of albums to mild critical acclaim and their music is grounded in blues. They were also very popular via radio hits/7 nation army. They are the ‘Rolling Stones’ of our generation.

    TV in the Radio represented a ‘new race’ breaking into a genre dominated by a different race. They are the ‘Eminem’ of our generation.

    Girls is a band about expressing ur feelings. The Girls are from San Francisco and are always on drugs. They are the “1960s” of our generation.

    Who is the _______ of our generation?

    Reply

    funky_rutabaga

    //////////Reply by funky_rutabaga
    //////////Posted

    @brobro,

    The Black Angels – The Velvet Underground of our generation

    Fleet Foxes – The CSNY of our generation

    Dirty Projectors – I am pretty sure there were no bands like them “in” other generations

    Kurt Vile – The hybrid Lou Reed/GBV of our generation

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @funky_rutabaga, Dirty Projectors was Talking Heads. Black Angels can’t be VU, no ones ever heard of them

    Reply

    pookie

    //////////Reply by pookie
    //////////Posted

    @funky_rutabaga, luv the black angels

    Reply

    silverstar

    //////////Reply by silverstar
    //////////Posted

    @funky_rutabaga, were you alive 5 years ago?

    Reply

    jvac

    //////////Reply by jvac
    //////////Posted

    @funky_rutabaga, The raveonettes= velvet underground of our generation

    Reply

    grant golland

    //////////Reply by grant golland
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, ac is more like pink floyd i think
    who is our bob dylan?

    Reply

    pookie

    //////////Reply by pookie
    //////////Posted

    @grant golland, naws…ac is totes beach boyz of r gen.

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, works for me, they sound pretty much the same as the beach boys

    carolina

    //////////Reply by carolina
    //////////Posted

    @grant golland, think our generation’s bob dylan is probably conor, via ‘thought-provoking/protest-generated’ lyrics/poetry & prolificacy.

    either that, or joaquin phoenix-bro (not the ‘19k1′ guys, but the gladiator bro) for completely mind-fucking the media cuz he can.

    Reply

    \\\\\\\\\\

    //////////Reply by \\\\\\\\\\
    //////////Posted

    @grant golland, feel that Jay Z really captured the zeitgeist, we can all relate to his struggle (via living in Brooklyn & other urban centers). Kinda like how Bob’s hair looked all crazy some times.

    Reply

    lazerbear

    //////////Reply by lazerbear
    //////////Posted

    @grant golland, conor oberst = bob dylan 2.0

    Reply

    jvac

    //////////Reply by jvac
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, i concede to oberstbro = dylanbro

    Blackface Killah

    //////////Reply by Blackface Killah
    //////////Posted

    @grant golland, heard the argument that Conor Bright Eyes is our Bob Dylan before. He might be the closest we’ve got, but since Bob Dylan is ‘way fucking better’, that just means we don’t really have a Bob Dylan. Except the real Bob Dylan of course, who is still alive and releasing amazing records. Our Bob Dylan is Bob Dylan.

    Reply

    pookie

    //////////Reply by pookie
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, good listings.

    Reply

    \\\\\\\\\\

    //////////Reply by \\\\\\\\\\
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, Girl Talk is the Reel Big Fish of ‘our generation’

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @\\\\\, loled and agreed

    Reply

    kbiz

    //////////Reply by kbiz
    //////////Posted

    @d00dz, Kevin Barnes is the David Bowie of our generation [via glam/reinventions/hugedick].

    brobro

    //////////Reply by brobro
    //////////Posted

    Yall, is chillwave the disco of our generation?

    Reply

    andyp

    //////////Reply by andyp
    //////////Posted

    “Dirty Projectors – I am pretty sure there were no bands like them “in” other generations”

    I dont understand the hype, they are a total rip-off of jade tree records 90’s bands such as cap n jazz, joan of arc, dude, you don’t even have to dig that far to see where each band has ripped off, DP still have to grow a bit to get all the kudos that they are getting.

    Reply

    DayGlowwed

    //////////Reply by DayGlowwed
    //////////Posted

    @andyp, most ridiculous claim I’ve ever heard

    gaudi

    //////////Reply by gaudi
    //////////Posted

    @andyp, dirty projjies sound nothing like cap’n jazz or joan of arc. youre just trying to grab some ‘cred’ by namedropping.

    ThatsNotAltBro

    //////////Reply by ThatsNotAltBro
    //////////Posted

    @andyp, Dirty Projectbros are better becuz those bands all recorded in a bathroom @ Dennys

    derderder

    //////////Reply by derderder
    //////////Posted

    @andyp,
    I dont understand the hype, they are a total rip-off of bands such as pavement, sonic youth, husker du, liquid liquid, max tundra, franny & zooey by salinger, michel foucault, baudrillard, the graduate (book, not movie), existentialism, chuck klosterman, _______, _______, _______, dude, you don’t even have to dig that far to see where each has been ripped off.

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, one of my irl bffs posited the same radiohead=beatles, anco=beach boys theories to me. secretly hoping u r him.

    Reply

  22. generk witty cmmnt
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:23 pm | Permalink

    DCFC = band of the decade.

    don’t care how hip it is to hate them.
    don’t care how they’re ‘mnstrm’ now.
    probs influenced many ppl on this board when they realized for the first time that they were ’so much different’ than the people in their freshman english class.

    we have the facts ['00]
    4bidden love ep ['00]
    photo album ['01]
    trans ['03]

    Reply

    hey anony anony

    //////////Reply by hey anony anony
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt, i need yall s0 much closer…

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt,

    I can’t stop feeling like our age and access to broadband Internet are the two of the most important factors in determining the musical journey that we would take to become the alt we r today.

    Since I was born in 1.9k87, I was only 13 when “we have the facts” and “4bidden luv” entered the world. I was “too young” – Phoenix. I was listening to trance, hard house, and ska with my bf who purchased “wheels of steel” from a dj catalog. haha it wasn’t until Pennsylvania Governor’s School of Information Technology, summer school, summer 2k4 that i realized [via fellow alts] that DCFC was an important band. i had downloaded “we have the facts” and “photo album”. he gave me [via flash drive] 4bidden luv and trans. i h8 2 admit it, but that band meant the world to me.

    If i had been born a couple years earlier or later, DCFC might have meant more or less 2 me.

    Reply

    laurn

    //////////Reply by laurn
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt, <3

    Reply

    Anonymous

    //////////Reply by Anonymous
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt, I think i agree.

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt,
    so sadly agree with you, but nobody else ever will admit to it. dcfc changed how all these kids listen to music now, even though what they are listening to now is ‘totally different’….they were all luvin the death cab back in the day….dont deny the phase. it happened. you know it. even though you listen to a.) griz bear/beach haus/bon iver/st vincent b.) chromeo/neon things/the xx c.) fidget/house/dub step now.

    Reply

  23. Cannibal Astronaut
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:26 pm | Permalink

    fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

    WE KILLED ‘INDIE’ Y’ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply

    antithesis

    //////////Reply by antithesis
    //////////Posted

    @Cannibal Astronaut, can i speak to god via you????

    Reply

    Cannibal Astronaut

    //////////Reply by Cannibal Astronaut
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis, I am ‘god’

    Reply

  24. can i get a meep?
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:47 pm | Permalink

    grizzly bear wins hand down y’all for the decade..does it really matter that they are too new?

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @can i get a meep?, Fuck. You.

    Reply

    lazerbear

    //////////Reply by lazerbear
    //////////Posted

    @can i get a meep?, grizz bear is great, but they don’t define our decade. they define the end product that all the process of our decade lead to.

    they are the end result, not the process.

    Reply

    abeewon

    //////////Reply by abeewon
    //////////Posted

    @can i get a meep?, grizz bear = hella ovvverated i struggle with calling them “decent/listenable”

    Reply

  25. Elie
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:47 pm | Permalink

    What about Broken Social Scene… just because they haven’t put out a real album in a few years it’s like everyone has forgotten about how seminal that shit was. Too crucial.

    Reply

    grant golland

    //////////Reply by grant golland
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, self-titled is in the running for my favorite album ever. Also, their “non-existent supergroup formula” is one that I think will gain popularity in the coming years.

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @grant golland, They are by no means my favourite band but I automatically associate their sound with the aims of the ‘indie’ aesthetic of our generation, though this just may be my Toronto bias.
    Also I think it’s hard to ignore the influence of MGMT in shaping the sound and image of the past 2 years or so.

    and I would also like to throw the words Daft Punk into discussion – I think it is crazy to overlook their work, even their late 90’s significance in the O’s

    Finally though many would scoff at the mention I think Welcome to Jamrock by Damian Marley gave us the heaviest dirtiest – most autotune-free reggae single since god knows when. Listen to that shit again hipsters and tell me that doesn’t make you want to burn your neighbours house down.

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, had me at BroBro So; lost me at BroMarley

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, Maybe just a guilty pleasure

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, totes agree. u forgot it in ppl is my fave album of the 2k0s. feel like it is ‘fucking amazing’ and ‘representative’ of the decade

    Reply

    pookie

    //////////Reply by pookie
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, way agreed. totes luv brendan canning’s solo shit 2.

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, I was thinking of another one a little too obvious but if were gonna talk about radiohead’s significance at all I say we toss in a small dose of Yankee Foxtrot…everyone should have a softspot for the “hillbilly ok computer?”

    Reply

  26. Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:49 pm | Permalink

    I would like to nominate our music blog welistenforyou.com for your list. We are a hang out spot for people who hate Vampire Weekend and bros looking for some music love. We listen to five albums a day and sift through the junk for our readers. Plus we haven’t switched from Blogger to Word Press like all the cool blogs, so we are kinda alt-bashful-vintage.

    Reply

  27. cjt
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 6:50 pm | Permalink

    Love how some of the comments ape Carles’s writing style (and fail). None of you are Carles.

    Reply

    HJ

    //////////Reply by HJ
    //////////Posted

    @cjt, just had a self realization yall!!!!

    Reply

    antithesis

    //////////Reply by antithesis
    //////////Posted

    @HJ, wat!?!?

    Reply

    HJ

    //////////Reply by HJ
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRogmcixV_M&feature=related

    jerryseinfelds

    //////////Reply by jerryseinfelds
    //////////Posted

    @cjt, so deep, yall

    Reply

    carles

    //////////Reply by carles
    //////////Posted

    @cjt,
    i’m wearing a shirt that says “i am carles” on it, ergo, I am Carles.

    Reply

    jig

    //////////Reply by jig
    //////////Posted

    @cjt, luv bros who use ‘ape’ as a verb… tell me ur not just ‘aping the effing shit out of writer/blogger x’ when u do this… we are all apes (plural noun), I suppose. but when we ‘ape’ (verbie), we’re all just trying to find a little offshoot of that particular word-river so we can have our own special salmon babies away from the grizzbear(s) (metaphoric animal, not band)… ULTIMATELY (a horrible way 2 start a sentence always), I think w/ this ’style’ the words are trying to die… and I think we need to let them die becuz unlike hip new movies like the avatar there’s not a lot of ‘cool fx’ we can add 2 lame old words/sentences/paragraphs/blogposts/post apocolyptic semi-mnstrm novels… so let’s all just kill em w/ horrible internetspeak + bad grammar and whatever else, right? originality is totes overrated, I pray @ the church of entertainment… our jesusbro is a picture of a grasshopper drawn by a 4yearold… that’s rly all

    Reply

  28. matt
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 7:03 pm | Permalink

    American Idol was relevant for the music industry, but I doubt that anybody except other American Idol contestants are going to give a shit about it when making music in the next decade. Hook-laden bubblegum pop has existed for a long time; it wasn’t innovative and it won’t be influential.

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @matt, What’s American Idol?

    Reply

  29. Posted December 16, 2009 at 7:10 pm | Permalink

    Think The Black Angels and Bon Iver are the most overlooked bands of this decade.

    Think Deerhunter and Atlas Sound (plus the above two) are the best bands of the decade (plus Girls)

    AnCo > Radiohead.

    Reply

    antithesis

    //////////Reply by antithesis
    //////////Posted

    @funky_rutabaga, Pitchfork isn’t big on the black angels….should i still check ‘em out and give them a chance??

    Reply

    DayGlowwed

    //////////Reply by DayGlowwed
    //////////Posted

    @antithesis, absolutely if you like things like BJM, Dead Meadow, Elephant Stone and the like

    Reply

  30. Y2K
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 7:35 pm | Permalink

    to be honest, never understood nor pretedned to understand radiohead hype, and always left me confused : S

    Reply

    pookie

    //////////Reply by pookie
    //////////Posted

    @Y2K, u r not alone.

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @pookie, so agreed

    Reply

  31. hey anony anony
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:04 pm | Permalink

    00s alt_niche: alexandrapatsavascore?

    did u play ‘hide and seek’ when coop shot her bf’s bro?
    did u ‘just lay here’ when merry and mcdreamie were ______?
    did yall actually ’save a life’ when the fraybro was afraid of a for serious relaish?
    did yall join n e a cappella groups after lil j sang ‘glamorous’ at constance?
    did n e 1 listen 2 lil j’s IRL indie rock group?
    did yall watch grey’s/gossip girl/the o.c. (via thee oh sees) ‘before it was cool’?

    miss mixes, yall. miss ’seth cohen starter packs.’ miss helicopter parenting+the meaningfulcore music of adorable altjews.

    Reply

    generk witty cmmnt

    //////////Reply by generk witty cmmnt
    //////////Posted

    more relevant fictional altjew:

    seth cohen or andrew largeman

    Reply

    lazerbear

    //////////Reply by lazerbear
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt,

    adam goldberg, a.k.a. the HEBREW HAMMER

    Reply

    Willd

    //////////Reply by Willd
    //////////Posted

    @lazerbear, lol

    Jarden Mears-Dagan

    hey anony anony

    //////////Reply by hey anony anony
    //////////Posted

    @generk witty cmmnt, alan greenspan

    i’m concerned (via tim gunn) that carles ‘forgot about altjews.’

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @hey anony anony, carry on, yall

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @hey anony anony, I would like to nominate myself for the most relevant altjew – and to the rest of the tribe enjoy the final night of Chanuka – zeit gazunt and light those candles peoples

  32. jimmm
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:10 pm | Permalink

    ProTools is the band of the decade.

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @jimmm, srlsy tho. i feel like technology offers the best explanation for what happened over the past 10 years. culture seemed to mostly react to technological development.

    Ableton Live > ProTools

    Musical Instrument Digital Interface for the band of the decade.
    p4k for the band of the decade
    bittorent for the band of the decade
    blogosphere for the band of the decade
    myspace for the band of the decade
    hypemachine for the band of the decade

    Reply

    jimmm

    //////////Reply by jimmm
    //////////Posted

    @SilverTell,
    I feel you bro.

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @jimmm,
    so true again.
    fuck it, i have a macbook pro….im the motha fuckin band of the decade, and so are you.

  33. Mr_Neffets
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:17 pm | Permalink

    Bros, I got two Pink Floyd shirts. does that mean I’m ‘not welcome’ in these parts?

    Reply

    Bebe

    //////////Reply by Bebe
    //////////Posted

    @Mr_Neffets, neffets backwards: s-t-e-f-f-e-n as in Jacob Steffen

    tehe

    Reply

    Mr_Neffets

    //////////Reply by Mr_Neffets
    //////////Posted

    @Bebe, I personally found it to be almost witty and somewhat catchy

    Reply

    Bebe

    //////////Reply by Bebe
    //////////Posted

    @Mr_Neffets, So sweet, so so sweet p.s. what happened to all the ‘donut on a string’ Halloween photos? I wasn’t tagged in any on facebook </3

    Mr_Neffets

    //////////Reply by Mr_Neffets
    //////////Posted

    @Bebe, No idea, I didn’t even get a picture of my elf attire, your bull killer costume [matadora], or that giant rubber band thing. Still got the deck of cards in my drawer though

    Rachel

    //////////Reply by Rachel
    //////////Posted

    @Mr_Neffets, HI JAKE

    Mr_Neffets

    //////////Reply by Mr_Neffets
    //////////Posted

    @Rachel, OH HAI RACHEL

  34. RoboRapist
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:38 pm | Permalink

    1.Jay-Z was the most relevant musician, I’d have to give the nod to Lil Wayne actually
    2.Most important artist? Beyonce?
    3.To state it quick, YES THE FUCK THEY ARE
    4.Wait… Um they’re new? I’m from Baltimore and fuck yeah the can be consider one of the best
    5.Numetal, The Strokes dropped the ball, after about the first album Interpol went shit, Crunk got all distorted and just became part of normal hip-hop and went to crap, girls like Fiona, and Venessa Carlton also fell off
    6.No, all the artist AI shitted out suck ass, except fantasia, Jordan Sparks and Kelly Clarkson, they haven’t had a real male sucess yet
    7. Yes, but men make better music
    8.Um… I don’t know, it was nothing in this decade that was super game changing like “Nevermind” or some shit, too many different sounds, too many fggt counter cultures that got stuck around Myspace and Youtube, there was no apathy generation X type crap one feeling shit
    9.Buzzbands allways existed, the internet didn’t, before the internet you had to rely on an MTV, Internet not going no wher neither is dem buzz bands
    10. Shit… just music wise, Radiohead! YEAH I SAID THAT SHIT! No real mainstrm band this decade has touched The Beatles in popularity. I would probably be some rapper like Kanye or Lil Weasle
    11.Fuck Tweens, and you had to years to get down with new p2p and bittorrent and shit.
    12.Seriously indie, yes I said it, it got lumped in with that emo shit this decade, and the most overlooked band? A lot, the most overlooked genre? Neo Soul, so shut the fuck up
    13.As a black person. fuck yeah, half of the “revolutionary” rap, and hip-hop has been bullshit, and tired of hearing about Kanye making some mediocre CD about his Heart on and 808 that other lame, non hip blk kids didn’t here, tired of P4K dick riding that crappy Gucci mane, tired of Lil Wayne fggt in my face. Hip-Hop is old, we know you are multi cultured, give that shit a rest, black publications need to give more cite to dudes like TV On the Radio who show that niggers can do more than rap about money, bitches, and hoes
    14.Bono Bro! Flaming Lips Bro(right?) a whole bunch of other bro
    15.No, they’re too cool for the Facebook
    16.Um… if they stop dicking around, um Juli Blanca’s solo deal was not mainstream enough so I say yeah, Strokes still have it
    17.????????????????????????? Yeah
    18.13 year old girls, anime freaks, 20 year old man-boys with bad hair and 12 year old boy voices hijacked it(see Panic! at the Disco)
    19.I got my first iPod in 2006, I’m a young guy I’m 20.
    20.2K0 fucking sucked for mainstream, mainstream is dead, if you look anywhere else yes there was good music… Know what fuck it, it was a good decade for music, if you weren’t looking in mainstream, better than the 90’s. but still Nirvana>>>>All

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @RoboRapist, tl;dr… srsly

    Reply

    jimmm

    //////////Reply by jimmm
    //////////Posted

    @RoboRapist, Venessa Carlton fell off? I saw her last summer at a local music festival in rural PA. Her brand still seems strong.

    Reply

    RoboRapist

    //////////Reply by RoboRapist
    //////////Posted

    @jimmm, To the mainstreamers, after “Thousand Miles” you didn’t here much from the girl, I still like her though.

    Reply

    ThatsNotAltBro

    //////////Reply by ThatsNotAltBro
    //////////Posted

    @RoboRapist,

    Yeah I Said it!

    Reply

  35. ohnosphaghetticat
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:50 pm | Permalink

    dont forget about

    Reply

    marisol

    //////////Reply by marisol
    //////////Posted

    @ohnosphaghetticat, me

    Reply

  36. aw, fukk
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:51 pm | Permalink

    just failed 2 finals today

    going to lose my full ride scholarship

    on top of that

    i only have 3 aspirin left

    so i cant OD

    how fucked up is my life

    Reply

    jig

    //////////Reply by jig
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, this guy is obvs voting 4 edybros the ‘fucked up’ as ‘decade’s best’

    Reply

    jig

    //////////Reply by jig
    //////////Posted

    @jig, ed_ybros; _ = g (w/e)

    Reply

    aw, fukk

    //////////Reply by aw, fukk
    //////////Posted

    @jig, bro

    antithesis

    //////////Reply by antithesis
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, sorry bro. where do u go to school? (me being sympathetic/creeper bro)

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, hope u feel better bro. failed 2 classes my junior year and i’m still graduating on time. yall can do it.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEhPVhSG7X4

    Reply

    aw, fukk

    //////////Reply by aw, fukk
    //////////Posted

    @chilisfan, thx bro, <3s

    rly like that song

    "c u on the tumblr!"

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, bro, I fucking love you bro. keep doing what you do.

    Reply

    jerryseinfelds

    //////////Reply by jerryseinfelds
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, aw, fukkkkk

    Reply

  37. simply j
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 8:56 pm | Permalink

    Susan Boyle was the best thing to happen to music this decade. Yall.

    Reply

    THE_JAKK

    //////////Reply by THE_JAKK
    //////////Posted

    @simply j, i’ve got a sweet susan boyle tatty ;)

    Reply

    Cindy Pepper

    //////////Reply by Cindy Pepper
    //////////Posted

    @simply j, Agreed. Susan revolutionized the music industry. Her “melt down” confirmed her alt status. <3 her!

    Reply

  38. JoBroLuver
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 9:09 pm | Permalink

    1.Jo Bros, I luv dem
    2.Um… Because Jo Bros made indie poplur on radio disney
    3.Nickleback, or Daughtry
    4.What’s radio head?
    5.I don’t know them eaither
    6.Wuts a genre, but Drake music came and went, but I still like Drake music Lil Waybe Hip-Hop music too
    7.OMG I LUV AMERICAN IDOL! The rock star guy is gunna be the best artist next decade
    8.The lead singe of Paramore
    9.Yes ;like fall out boys and stuff
    10.Lil Wayne
    11.No we go on iTunes, my dad buys ne muzic frum der
    12. Scene, Screamo
    13.???? Black Artist?
    14.Pete Wentz
    15.yeah they are real PPL! THEY ON THE TV!
    16.What is the Stroke?
    17. IDK who they are
    18.Emo is STILL AROUND! WHAT?
    19.Last year for Christmas

    Reply

  39. Posted December 16, 2009 at 9:13 pm | Permalink

    For me: First it was Bright Eyes, when I was a sad lil tween.
    Then it was Boards of Canada in high school.
    I can’t choose single bands anymore. Stars of the Lid have composed probably the most singularly beautiful music this decade. HEALTH managed to make noise rock that’s as catchy as pop. M.I.A. redefined what I perceived about ‘hip hop’.

    People will say either The Radioheads or Animals Collection as the one and only band, depending on their level of ‘undergroundness’, but they’re obvious choices and leave a lot out of the picture. If anything, the 2000s were the decade where ‘a single, defining band’ ceased to matter.

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @apreludes, i enjoi ur episodic multimedia book.

    Technology for band of the decade.
    We’re living in a post-band world, yall – CRLS 2k10

    Reply

  40. even stevens
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 9:18 pm | Permalink

    feel like as a musik lover i need 2 answer all of these questions individually.

    -most relevant artist was either anco or jay-z (am i allowed to have to choices that are completely different and neither are really right for this title?)
    -indie was born out of the world wide web and the killers’ song “indie rock & roll”
    -artist of decade is prolly radiohead
    -so i guess radiohead could be most important band of “our generation”
    -anco is not 2 new to be considered because they formed in 2000, making them perfect for this decade
    -emo totally came in our faces and then left. so did reggaeton, r.i.p. gasolina!
    -american idle was only relevant to t.v. watchers, and i am 2 alt to have a t.v.
    -womyn r important 2 the music scene because they r hot
    -vampire weekend made white people like african music
    -buzzbands will always exist
    -the beatles are “the beatles” of the decade because their singles album “1″ is the bestselling album of the decade
    -tweens only like vampires right? so they don’t listen to music
    - religious rock was TOTES overlooked. praise jesus/adonai/allah/etc.
    -alt music zines just over-represent black musicians on “best of” lists because they under-represent them the rest of the time
    -jobros sing about diabetes – aka most undersung cause of all time
    -musicians are human beings just like u & me. WE WISH.
    -strokes don’t have alt cred, but every individual member does… weird
    -arcade fire was really that good, and still are. i think
    -emo took a poop
    -first ipod in preskewl because i am 7 and parents are rich
    -2k0 was not the best, sorta sad. but because i am 7, it is all i know.

    thanks for listening y’all

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @even stevens,

    -indie was born out of the world wide web and the killers’ song “indie rock & roll”
    hehe

    -artist of decade is prolly radiohead
    *prolly* hehe

    -emo totally came in our faces and then left. so did reggaeton, r.i.p. gasolina!
    *r.i.p. gasolina* hehe

    “womyn r important 2 the music scene because they r hot” FTW!

    “alt music zines just over-represent black musicians on “best of” lists because they under-represent them the rest of the time” lol

    “strokes don’t have alt cred, but every individual member does… weird” come to think of it. huh true

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @even stevens, pretty funny
    vampire weekend made me like Paul Simon…

    Reply

  41. michaelrichards
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 9:23 pm | Permalink

    The weirdest thing about this decade is meeting children that were born after 2k1, and realizing that they’re old enough to talk.

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @michaelrichards, *shivers* woah

    Reply

  42. hjznbluntz
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 9:29 pm | Permalink

    cam’ron + the diplomats = greatest of the decade. most influential.

    SUCK A DICK no homo

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @hjznbluntz, lol

    Reply

  43. DaveyTareCat
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 9:42 pm | Permalink

    It actually turns out the AnCo was the beatles, pink floyd, and beach boys of our gen. Radiohead was creedence clear water revival. AnCO #1, Deerhunters #2 yo.

    Reply

    treefingers

    //////////Reply by treefingers
    //////////Posted

    @DaveyTareCat, kute name.

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @treefingers, thanks. U must be hardcore into ambient muic, huh?

    Reply

    treefingers

    //////////Reply by treefingers
    //////////Posted

    @DaveyTareCat, bros always knows, bros always knows

    As the most visionary collective to ever walk the earth once sang,
    “support ur brother (sports brother)”

    woodbro wilson

    //////////Reply by woodbro wilson
    //////////Posted

    @DaveyTareCat, ur wrong bro. deerhunter isnt even in the same league as r-head. they r good, but they’re like the turtles to radiohead’s beatles. they dont compare.

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @woodbro wilson, your Probably right I guess. It’s just really hard for me to like things now that I liked when I was younger/a virgin. R-head I mean

    Reply

    woodbro wilson

    //////////Reply by woodbro wilson
    //////////Posted

    @DaveyTareCat, u make a fine point sir

  44. aw, fukk
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 10:32 pm | Permalink

    capgun coup = <3

    Reply

    aw, fukk

    //////////Reply by aw, fukk
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, http://leftshoedistrict.tumblr.com/post/285685157/adorable-doorsteps-by-capgun-coup

    Reply

    aw, fukk

    //////////Reply by aw, fukk
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, damn, heres another

    http://leftshoedistrict.tumblr.com/post/287099637/still-on-capgun-coup-its-been-a-shitty-day

    Reply

    aw, fukk

    //////////Reply by aw, fukk
    //////////Posted

    @aw, fukk, feel like this might be a ‘better’ song in terms of substance

    Reply

  45. Posted December 16, 2009 at 11:08 pm | Permalink

    what abt the teenagers? aren’t they ur fave band, crls?

    feel like crls has forgotten his roots.

    nvr frgt the electro warz

    Reply

  46. brobro
    Posted December 16, 2009 at 11:12 pm | Permalink

    Feel like if u were a ‘pretentious fuck’/'p4k blogger/reviewer’ u would say:

    ‘Animal Collective’s music didn’t so much as define this decade as it defied it. They were the one band who was consistently one step ahead of everyone else this decade, doing what no one else could even think of doing. No one even dared to try copying them, and for that reason, they are the band of the decade.’

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, funny

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, successful satire. i disagree with the content tho. with the exception of “fireworks” their music is annoying pre-MPP.

    Reply

    chr!s

    //////////Reply by chr!s
    //////////Posted

    @SilverTell, silvertell me youre joking. the bees the bees the bees the bees.

    Reply

    DaveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by DaveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, well done.

    Reply

    sambone

    //////////Reply by sambone
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, I like how you wrote that, read it before you posted it, and then wrote “Feel like if u were a ‘pretentious fuck’/’p4k blogger/reviewer’ u would say:” on top.

    Reply

    brobro

    //////////Reply by brobro
    //////////Posted

    @sambone, You have reached the second layer of satire.

    Reply

    p4k/spin/subway ppr

    //////////Reply by p4k/spin/subway ppr
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, u want a ‘job’?

    Reply

  47. Posted December 16, 2009 at 11:27 pm | Permalink

    Michelle Branch

    p.s.

    @anjelicapickles
    who came first, you or eliza thornberry

    Reply

    jjj

    //////////Reply by jjj
    //////////Posted

    @Bebe, vanessa carlton > michelle branch

    white houses. hands down.

    Reply

    Bebe

    //////////Reply by Bebe
    //////////Posted

    @jjj, all right, all right, White Houses is great… about losing ur virg right? That one thousand miles song is also a fave.

    BUT SRSLY

    don’t think ur better than
    1) The Game of Love
    2) Everywhere
    and
    3) All You Wanted

    but if not, I’m sure we can all agree that “Complicated” by Avril Lavigne was the highlight of our elementary school radio-listening careers

    Reply

  48. okayokay
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 12:06 am | Permalink

    the strokes were the beatles of the decade.

    most overlooked alt movement was the brit-alt-rock NME scene of the early ’00s.

    Reply

  49. Posted December 17, 2009 at 12:45 am | Permalink

    Bloc Party
    Cut Copy
    The Presets
    Justice
    Daft Punk

    Reply

    anonymous

    //////////Reply by anonymous
    //////////Posted

    @le CEECEE, ಠ_ಠ

    Reply

    anonymous

    //////////Reply by anonymous
    //////////Posted

    @le CEECEE,

    you are so right about daft punk actually

    Reply

  50. Fredbro
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 1:29 am | Permalink

    Bob Dylan of 00s = blitzen trapperbro

    Reply

    tittyboy

    //////////Reply by tittyboy
    //////////Posted

    @Fredbro, no

    Reply

    chad

    //////////Reply by chad
    //////////Posted

    @fredbro, blitzen trapper bro is totes dylanbro of oo’s

    Reply

  51. Posted December 17, 2009 at 1:32 am | Permalink

    think M.I.A./Kala was the best artist/album/songs of 2k0s. how come i’m the only one?

    Reply

    tittyboy

    //////////Reply by tittyboy
    //////////Posted

    @chrysler5thavenue, because you are a complete idiot.

    M.I.A is absolute trash. sorry.

    Reply

    chrysler5thavenue

    //////////Reply by chrysler5thavenue
    //////////Posted

    @tittyboy, I am not buying that based on your post just below.

    Reply

    tittyboy

    //////////Reply by tittyboy
    //////////Posted

    @chrysler5thavenue,

    i want to curse at you, because i think you are foolish.

    I still stand by my opinion that MIA is complete trash, you can not tell me otherwise, because if you did, you would be lying.

    i know its usually a matter of opinion, but in this case its a matter of fact.

    woodbro wilson

    //////////Reply by woodbro wilson
    //////////Posted

    @tittyboy, agreed. i saw her at coachella and it was honestly just embarrassing to watch. but then the killers came on and it was like “hey cool”

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @chrysler5thavenue, I think M.I.A definitely helped define certain visual aestetics of the 00’s but i dunno how high I’d rank the tunes – still good stuff though… as for titty Neon indian and girls are easy picks cause they are still so fresh and easy too get excited over… having said that i spin psychic chasms on repeat… it would be interesting to see this list in 2 years even

    Reply

  52. tittyboy
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 1:43 am | Permalink

    OK.

    1. Animal Collective is overrated.
    2. Neon Indian was for me the most exciting music i heard this decade but is becoming too mainstream.
    3. Jay Z was cool in the 90s, fuck his last album and all the hype he gets lately.
    4. If the Girls Album or Neon Indian Psychic Chasms isn’t in your top ten of the decade, i might unsubscribe from your RSS feed.
    5. I’m not sure why im typing a list with numbers like this, i think i saw someone else do it, and it looked fun.
    6. Kanye West used to be a lot better early in the decade, though he did provide an amazing meme, that might be one of the greatest meme’s of all time.
    7. Michael Jackson didnt mean shit to me.
    8. I was born in 1983
    9. I dont remember enough of the last 9 years to tell you about the whole decade.
    10. i’m out ya’ll.

    Reply

    SilverTell

    //////////Reply by SilverTell
    //////////Posted

    @tittyboy, i lyke ur style

    MJ didn’t mean shit to me either. Anco is definitely overrated.

    Reply

    chr!s

    //////////Reply by chr!s
    //////////Posted

    @tittyboy, did you get a boner when you typed neon indian is getting too mainstream? durrrr hurrr durrrr. pretentious jackass.

    Reply

    ooooooooo

    //////////Reply by ooooooooo
    //////////Posted

    @chr!s,

    you want a tissue with that cry?

    Reply

    chad

    //////////Reply by chad
    //////////Posted

    @tittyboy, fggt

    Reply

    jjj

    //////////Reply by jjj
    //////////Posted

    @chad, Please don’t say that. Don’t say some1 is fggt when you mean some1 is dumb or stupid. It’s insulting. It’s like if I thought hro was stupid and I cmmtd ‘man, hro is so chad.’ Jus sayin. When you say fggt do you realize what you say? Knock it off. [via ms. sykes]

    Reply

    ThatsNotAltBro

    //////////Reply by ThatsNotAltBro
    //////////Posted

    @tittyboy,

    MJ is still the king,

    MJ > Neon Indian

    Reply

  53. Elie
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 1:52 am | Permalink

    In terms of hip hop – and 00′ music in general I have to say the late/great J-dilla derserves a serious nod – Donuts is one of the finest hiphop albums of all time and his posthumous material like the shining or Ruff draft is practically lo-fi scripture – it’s blood can be seen smeared all over glo-fi (quit whining it’s a perfectly fine name).

    Ghostface Killah takes my pick for greatest gangsta rapper of the decade big doe rehab – fishscale – i don’t care how tired hiphop has got I will listen to Ghostface rap about slinging crack anyday.

    Also I think Mos def should get some respect along with the Roots

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, agree agree agree

    also, everything MF Doom did, as well as everything affiliated with El-P. boom-bap haters can hate, but there was some dank shit going in hip hop this decade.

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @chilisfan, definitely can’t forget about Doom. I have also loved almost every album K-os has put out, though that may also be a Toronto thing.

    I feel like I am putting a bullseye on my head talking so much about hip hop on this blog – I just think that since there is so much ‘dank shit’ in hip hop it’s easy to count off a whole gestalt of music. If people are gonna be talking at all about hiphop here throwing out names like jayz and kanye it seems criminal not too mention Dilla, Doom etc.

    Reply

    tittyboy

    //////////Reply by tittyboy
    //////////Posted

    @Elie & Chilisfan, Hip hop/rap is played out ya’ll.

    time for new musics.

    With that being said, Madvillian was great at the time of its release, i dont think i’d enjoy it so much today.

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, don’t really get why p4k/hipsters feel the need to include token hip hop acts, and go straight for the mainstream hits. i mean i like jay-z and kanye is sometimes good (but usually a huge fggt), but madlib, doom, dilla, el-p, etc etc made WAY better music.

    woodbro wilson

    //////////Reply by woodbro wilson
    //////////Posted

    @chilisfan, Mouse And The Mask with Danger Mouse? How good, bro?

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @woodbro wilson, the 2k0s were all about great hip hop collabs. jaylib. madvillainy. felt. gnarls bark. ‘damn’ it feel good 2 b a gangsta.

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @woodbro wilson, & Chilis
    Totally don’t understand the deal with p4k love affairs with jayz and kanye and whoeverthefuck- it makes sense in certain scenarios ie. jayz toasting grizz or kanye using that guy who directed the justice vid – or if it has any relevance whatsoever to ‘our scene’ but if your goin to have a boner for the mainstream hip hop artists and not the guys experimenting and pushing it then they might as well be talk about mainstream rock charttoppers and the other garbage on the radio – which is all well and good – but out of place in an alternative music forum

  54. Elie
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 2:25 am | Permalink

    In terms of women ‘indie heavyweights’ with huge (mainstream) critical acclaim like fiest, now karen oh, as well as regina spektor and others can be telling of female dominion in alt. music – plus their is a delicious irony of indie influence via mainstream acclaim. We all love irony here don’t we?

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @Elie, agreeed lots of females finally competing for music. karen o is a fuckin real rock star of our time. alice glass also a badass. and then feist, reg speks, st. vincent, all doin their thing too.

    Reply

  55. Ziggy
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 3:25 am | Permalink

    What happened to emo? the kids realized how pathetic they were in their search for pre-fab authenticity and emotion; then turned into tongue-in-cheeck hipsters. to compensate for their ridiculous outfits/make-up/teenage angst. it’s a generational thing.

    Reply

    d00dz

    //////////Reply by d00dz
    //////////Posted

    @Ziggy, good analysis

    Reply

  56. monster
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 8:45 am | Permalink

    seriously think Let it Bloom by the Black Lips was one of the best rock n roll albums of the decade

    Reply

  57. woodbro wilson
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 11:32 am | Permalink

    arcade fire most definitely changed everyone’s idea of indie.

    Reply

    AveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by AveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @woodbro wilson, My problem with Arcade fire is that it’s proto ‘buttoned up, polite, fggt indie’. It ushered in a new era of bands that were polite and fggts. Like GrizzBear, Fleetfoxes, Andrew Bird, Bon Iver.

    Reply

    chilisfan

    //////////Reply by chilisfan
    //////////Posted

    @AveyTareCat, ‘Do ur homework’ bro. Belle & Seb, Elephant 6 bands, and Neutral Milk Hotel all predate Arcade Fire and all made polite fggtcore indie pop. And frankly, go back further and you’ll find Nick Drake, The Smiths, REM, U2… decades of politely artistic fggts making buttoned-up pretty pop-rock.

    Pretty sure Paul McCartney invented it.

    Reply

    uhuh

    //////////Reply by uhuh
    //////////Posted

    @chilisfan, NMH is not ‘polite fggtcore indie pop’

    but word 2 everything else you said.

  58. SMKBNZ88
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 11:54 am | Permalink

    i rode the bus yesterday and felt relevant

    Reply

  59. chr!s
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 12:28 pm | Permalink

    how many people are honestly evaluating the entire decade? im seeing too much 06-09 stuff. i challenge you to pick something good from 2000…

    mindless self indulgence FGWSSS

    Reply

    HJ

    //////////Reply by HJ
    //////////Posted

    @chr!s, i still jay to the video for oops i did it again by b. spears if that makes you feel better

    Reply

  60. ooooooooo
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 12:42 pm | Permalink

    Q.Who was the most relevant musician of the 2k0 decade?

    A. Alan Palomo

    Q.How did ‘indie’ become what it is?

    A. Mainstream

    Q.Who is ‘the most important artist of the decade’?

    A. Alan Palomo

    Q.Is Radiohead the most important band of ‘our generation’?

    A. No

    Q.Is ‘the Animal Collective’ too new 2 be considered on a best of decade list?

    A. Alan Palomo

    Q.Which genres/bands ‘came and went’?

    A. Probably too many to name

    Q.Was American Idol more relevant than the bloghouse/indie movement?

    A. close call, not sure which has the slightly higher number

    Q.Are women important 2 the music scene?

    A. Most definitely

    Q.Did 1 album/band change the world/scene?

    A. Alan Palomo

    Q.Will ‘buzzbands’ exist in the next decade?

    A. I dont see why not

    Q.Who is ‘the beatles’ of the decade?

    A. The Beatles

    Q.Do tweens know how to steal music since they never had a Napster console?

    A.I hope so

    Q.What genre/movement/band has been ‘overlooked’ in most Decade recapping posts?

    A. Alan Palomo

    Q.Have black artists been over-represented by ‘respected’ music zine sites?

    A. Only when mikebro blogs

    Q.Which musician did the most for the betterment of the world, besides making critically acclaimed albums?

    A. Alan Palomo or probably like Bono or one of those people who do fund raiser concerts etc.

    Q. Are musicians ‘real humans’, ‘artists’ or ‘a whole nother beast’?

    A. Maybe

    Q.Do the Strokes still have alternative credibility?

    A.Probably

    Q.Was the Arcade Fire really even ‘that good’?

    A. I didnt listen to them when they came out, listening now, its kewl

    Q.What ever happened 2 ‘emo’?

    A. Did it die when Conor Oberst made a country album?

    Q.When did u get ur first iPod?

    A. Was i supposed to remember that? 2004? The white one…

    Q.Was 2k0 the best decade in the history of music?

    A. like anyone could even know that – “kip”

    (There is a lot of kewl music out there, i just think the Neon Bro takes the cake for 09′ summer at least. Just my opinion.)

    Reply

  61. Chubs
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 1:17 pm | Permalink

    joy orbison? ariel pink’s haunted graffiti? R.Stevie Moore (been around longer than a decade, but still genius), and let us not forget about will smith, big willie style

    Reply

  62. utica
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 1:33 pm | Permalink

    at the drive-in

    Reply

    fouroh7

    //////////Reply by fouroh7
    //////////Posted

    @utica, mars

    Reply

  63. Blackface Killah
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 2:04 pm | Permalink

    The Avalanches. “Since I Left” you dropped in ‘01 and everybody has been trying to catch up unsuccessfully ever since. And when their 2.0 record comes out, it will surely take indie musician bro’s the next decade to catch up.

    Reply

    Elie

    //////////Reply by Elie
    //////////Posted

    @Blackface Killah, I back Avalanches hard bro

    Reply

  64. whatsmyageagain
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 2:31 pm | Permalink

    BLINK 182!!! can’t forget the enema of the state.

    Reply

  65. INEVERPOST
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 2:52 pm | Permalink

    Did the whole world forget about S.M. and the Jicks?

    I figured that out of four solid albums at least one would make a decade list somewhere…

    sigh…

    Reply

  66. fernando
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 3:00 pm | Permalink

    Miss Kittin’s Frank Sinatra preceded this decade’s pop culture. And I feel like Nellie McKay’s the only authentic act to emerge from the it.

    Reply

    HJ

    //////////Reply by HJ
    //////////Posted

    @fernando, therrrrre was something in the air that night the stars were briiiiiiiight……………..

    Reply

  67. silverstar
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 3:08 pm | Permalink

    best band of 2k9 = Salem (p4k ratings out of whack)
    best band of 2k8 = Crystal Castles (best of the bloghouse)
    best band of 2k7 = Of Montreal (HFAYMD = last great monument of emo)
    best band of 2k6 = Grizzbear (YH>Vecky)
    best band of 2k5 = AnCo (Feels>MPP)
    best band of 2k4 = bad year, ill give it to Arcade Fire
    best band of 2k3 = The Books (indie experimental has taken a recent hit)
    best band of 2k2 = Wilco. DUH
    best band(s) of 2K1 = too hard between The Microphones and M83 (ever listen to their first album?)
    best band(s) of Y2K = THREE way tie (also top three on p4k, but I didn’t know what p4k was back then) = Radiohead, Sigur Ros and Modest Mouse.

    WTF happened to music in 2K_?
    Seems like a steady decline. Fuck p4k/hypem/last.fm/blogging. I feel like I saw this happening when I first got into Kid A. Indie lost its ‘real’ emotion. Electronica became the norm. Experimental doesn’t make sense any more. Its all a stupid experiment lacking an adequate hypothesis. Neon indian is decent, but gets really fucking old after 4 listens. Bands like Wilco have (had) a heart and made music you could connect to for a lifetime. Not anymore. and the xx, GIVE ME A FUCKING BREAK!!!! deerhunter? what?
    Miss jesus ect.
    miss the glow pt. 2
    miss ‘good music’

    REALLLLLY miss Jeff Mangum

    Reply

    b4hc

    //////////Reply by b4hc
    //////////Posted

    @silverstar, miss u angry phil

    Reply

  68. erbear
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 3:10 pm | Permalink

    Wilco, anyone?

    Reply

    erbear

    //////////Reply by erbear
    //////////Posted

    @erbear,

    and I don’t mean ‘Sky Blue Sky’ or ‘Wilco (The Album)…I’m talking Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. It was probably one of the last albums they put out that was actually amazing. Sky Blue Sky and Wilco (The Album), however, totally did not strike me as ‘amazing’ in the least.

    Reply

    scraperbike

    //////////Reply by scraperbike
    //////////Posted

    @erbear, Yankee Hotel is brilliant, nice call

    Reply

    spaghetti

    //////////Reply by spaghetti
    //////////Posted

    @erbear, a ghost is born wuz good…wilco+piano=pretty kewl

    Reply

    erbear

    //////////Reply by erbear
    //////////Posted

    @spaghetti, ah you’re right! I do love a ghost is born as well

  69. Myth
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 3:21 pm | Permalink

    Justice/DaftPunk

    They changed EVERYTHING!!!!

    Reply

    Hmmm

    //////////Reply by Hmmm
    //////////Posted

    @Myth, I totes agree. could listen to them all day everyday.

    Reply

  70. scraperbike
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 4:01 pm | Permalink

    Arcade Fire is about as cool as The Polyphonic Spree(side note: The Polyphonic Spree is not fucking cool at all – Arcade Fire can suck my peen)

    Reply

  71. jerryseinfelds
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 4:20 pm | Permalink

    feel like illinoise was the best album of the last 20 years…feel like that comment will bring much hate.

    feel like the only person to ‘hate’ anco

    Reply

    blahblah

    //////////Reply by blahblah
    //////////Posted

    @jerryseinfelds, like anco and sufy stevs…

    Reply

  72. Posted December 17, 2009 at 4:40 pm | Permalink

    http://www.myspace.com/uffie *

    *just kidding, but damn, bro. thought you’d be all over that.

    Reply

    weed

    //////////Reply by weed
    //////////Posted

    @yvynyl,

    thanks now im reminded of this mess.

    this chick needs a rapping coach.

    Reply

  73. brobro
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 6:28 pm | Permalink

    Probably hard to blog new content in the midst of finals. I feel you bro.

    Reply

    achillbro

    //////////Reply by achillbro
    //////////Posted

    @brobro, he gradgied school, hes just putting together a ‘marathon’ HRO classic post right now on the two thousand zero zeros

    Reply

  74. Elle
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 8:54 pm | Permalink

    Dear HPSTRRNFF;

    I had to adblock that big ass ad for your merch because that girl’s dead eyes were creeping me out. Sorry :’(

    Cordially, Elle.

    Reply

    gaston

    //////////Reply by gaston
    //////////Posted

    @Elle, yr just jealous

    Reply

  75. AveyTareCat
    Posted December 17, 2009 at 10:31 pm | Permalink

    It’s just so weird how Animal Collective is unanimously excepted as the greatest band/song/album of the decade/century by everyone who listens to music. It’s weird how every song they ever released got a 10 on p4k and every album got BNM’d. Have you ever heard ‘Spirit They’ve Gone..’? Weird how they started at the very beginning of the decade and released their opus at the very end. Like they’re a band just for us.

    Will kids in 2020 gen read online about AC kinda like how we read online about My Bloody Valentine and The Smiths and The Pixies and The Vlvt Undrgrd?

    Reply

    ganggangbangbang

    //////////Reply by ganggangbangbang
    //////////Posted

    @AveyTareCat,
    r u fucking retarded? AC is consensus overrated. Its good but its so damn formulaic. Hopefully peope will be wise enough in the future to look at AC and recognize it as horrible overrated shit. AC cant be mentioned in the same sentence as any of those bands!

    Reply

    ThatsNotAltBro

    //////////Reply by ThatsNotAltBro
    //////////Posted

    @ganggangbangbang,

    Every band/artist no matter how good receives backlash 2 yrs after their peak. Doesn’t mean shit.

    And AnCo are overrated but also the best band in the world at the same time…

    Reply

    AltBrooklyBro

    //////////Reply by AltBrooklyBro
    //////////Posted

    @ThatsNotAltBro,
    lol anco best band in the world, you AC fanboys are hilarious. Animal Collective is grossly overrated and i believe that they will likely be remembered as a hype/buzz band of the 00’s

    Ari

    //////////Reply by Ari
    //////////Posted

    @AveyTareCat, gotta <3 people with small record collections

    Reply

    AveyTareCat

    //////////Reply by AveyTareCat
    //////////Posted

    @Ari, got <3 people with small penises.

    Reply

  76. Big Ol' Juicy Bro
    Posted December 18, 2009 at 12:53 am | Permalink

    awww i am excited 4 strokes 4. could be the best album of next year. or at least one of the best! i guess its hard to pin band of the decade because the 00’s were especially transitional period. u cant say shit like radiohead, but u also cant say ac, neither works

    Reply

  77. Posted December 18, 2009 at 1:46 am | Permalink

    Twitter was probably the best band. like ‘person of the year’ was you.

    http://www.pluggd.in/twitter-music-tune-sc140-297/

    Reply

  78. KanyeBro
    Posted December 18, 2009 at 3:24 am | Permalink

    hey yall, im really happy for you & ima let you finish, but michael jackson was the best artist of all time.

    OF ALL TIME.

    Reply

  79. fu
    Posted December 18, 2009 at 6:49 am | Permalink

    wats the best AnCo EP/album y’all?

    Reply

    erbear

    //////////Reply by erbear
    //////////Posted

    @fu, I’d say strawberry jam.

    Reply

    COBRO

    //////////Reply by COBRO
    //////////Posted

    @fu, prospect hummer is more relevent bro

    Reply

    anjelica pickles

    //////////Reply by anjelica pickles
    //////////Posted

    @fu, sunt tongs is most meaningful

    Reply

    anjelica pickles

    //////////Reply by anjelica pickles
    //////////Posted

    @anjelica pickles,

    cunt tongs lol

    Reply

    Becca

    //////////Reply by Becca
    //////////Posted

    @anjelica pickles, cunt songs was an Ani DiFranco album from 1998

    Al X

    //////////Reply by Al X
    //////////Posted

    @fu, Feels was chill defs did halucygens to that.

    Reply

  80. ANAN
    Posted December 18, 2009 at 7:29 am | Permalink

    everything ’song’ from 2007 bro

    Reply

  81. scraperbike
    Posted December 18, 2009 at 9:16 am | Permalink

    Best artist of the 2k’s, gotta be Daughtry, or Nickelback, maybe even ‘Seether’

    Reply

    brobro

    //////////Reply by brobro
    //////////Posted

    @scraperbike, s00 derivative yall. Creed was the original. & now they have been ‘resurrected’ to become the best band of the 2,010s.

    Reply

    Jacke

    //////////Reply by Jacke
    //////////Posted

    @brobro,

    Daughtry?
    surely you jest.
    I thought this blog was called ‘Hipster Runoff’ as opposed to “Philistine WT Redneck Runoff” ?

    Reply

  82. Posted December 18, 2009 at 1:56 pm | Permalink

    i like the 90’s the most.

    Reply

  83. Posted December 18, 2009 at 2:00 pm | Permalink

    hey y’all! tegan and sara just ‘came out’ with a new album! after work ima pick up a jug of hornitos and stop by tower records to pick me up one of their CDs!

    Reply

  84. uhuh
    Posted December 19, 2009 at 1:16 am | Permalink

    Atlas Sound

    Logos is pritty relevant

    or anything by kranky records

    yeughhh

    Reply

  85. gottabeanony
    Posted December 19, 2009 at 4:37 am | Permalink

    Daft Punk. Music too fucking amazing for words. Actually, their music is otherworldly. NO lies.

    Reply

  86. realzz?
    Posted December 19, 2009 at 4:43 am | Permalink

    umm…the ELECTRO wars were def FUCKING influential, i would say. DON’T FORGET pllzz.

    time of my life right there.

    Reply

  87. kiwibahamas
    Posted December 19, 2009 at 12:32 pm | Permalink

    TTA, anyone?

    Reply

  88. Posted December 21, 2009 at 12:52 am | Permalink

    Ariel Pink is the most important artist of the decade.
    Ladytron was also influential, but Ladytron was too sophisticated and had too much ’sang froid’ for gung-ho meat eating Americans to appreciate, so most will say that GrizzlyBear/AnCo were big deals, but you can only get so much mileage out of jerking off over Brian Wilson, who actually composed an album entitled “Smile”….

    thus is Mango

    Reply

    Ariel Pink

    //////////Reply by Ariel Pink
    //////////Posted

    @Jacke,
    damn.
    feel like you’re picking me to seem ‘authentic’

    Reply

  89. Posted December 21, 2009 at 1:17 am | Permalink

    one more thing:

    if we didn’t have yoko ono we would never have karen finley
    if we didn’t have karen finley we would never have peaches
    if we didn’t have peaches we would never have Fanny Pack
    if we didn’t have Fanny Pack we would never have Lady GaGa

    Reply

    laurn

    //////////Reply by laurn
    //////////Posted

    @Jacke, purrfection

    also yall:

    best album that NO one knows about, and should.

    http://girlfriends.bandcamp.com/album/girlfriends

    (free, you won’t regret it)

    Reply

  90. eyepatch
    Posted December 22, 2009 at 3:42 am | Permalink

    article = tldr
    cmmts = tldr
    09= more ceb’s die we got a week or so left make it count!

    Reply

  91. Peg
    Posted December 22, 2009 at 5:05 am | Permalink

    it’s bad timing anyways, but man, i’m just going to be unable to sleep since you put chan marshall in the same category as katy perry and pink. boo ‘carles’, boo.

    Reply

  92. dudee...
    Posted December 29, 2009 at 1:35 am | Permalink

    WTF!
    you forgot about Wavves, dude!

    Reply

Post a Comment, Yall!

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked * In order to manage your own avatar, link your email address to an OpenID**

*
*